I thought I might as well get this "poll" going.
I vote phpBB2.
I second that.
I say phpBB also.
I vote for simple machines Forum
phpBB ftw.
You could even do a joomla setup if you want it to mimic the current one. I did the site for my computer club in Joomla and it's great, has tons of plug ins, and helps me as a president keep things in order.
www.tidycms.com
I did the theme using an existing one, and changing images and colors and whatnot, worked out well, but we need a new header, I'm just terrible at doing creative things though.
not very active right now, but check it out, and if you have any questions, let me know!
Are we decided on phpbb2 then? There is one already setup and ready for me to begin porting data once we've decided this is the way to go.
phpbb, phpbb3 should be released soon, its in Release candidate right now though
Even if phpbb3 became stable tomorrow, I still wouldn't want to go with it. The code base is too fresh; it will need to go through the wash a couple times to see how it does, hehe.
Well I thought a lot more people were going to vote, but I would like to see the changes... I am CAOS addicted!
I know I heard one vote for Beast at the meeting... I'm waiting till Friday to cast my vote though.
I change my vote to Joomla. I took a look at the code base, and Joomla is MUCH more maintainable. It uses a better class layout and makes better use of design patterns. I would much prefer to help with that one, and it's the one I'm installing on my own site as well.
Well if Grim thinks Joomla is better, then I'm all for it as well. I'll trust his judgement.
Plus it looks like it has a ton of extensions that are a lot easier to integrate. (Including lots of Galleries)
Joomla is fine with me too, anything is better than xoops.
What about M$ Publisher?
QuoteI change my vote to Joomla. I took a look at the code base, and Joomla is MUCH more maintainable. It uses a better class layout and makes better use of design patterns. I would much prefer to help with that one, and it's the one I'm installing on my own site as well.
I just finished looking at the Joomla site and I must say I'm pretty impressed. Joomla gets my official vote!
QuoteWhat about M$ Publisher?
For a forum?!?!? Eh?!?!? :-? :-? :-?
Muahaha! I have corrupted more for Joomla. lol Good choice!
There's an extension to do just about anything in joomla... and if there isn't one, you can make one in a few hours. lol, wish I knew PHP better.
I'm in favor of phpBB.
Joomla looks pretty good to me.
Lets give it a shot.
I was able to set up Joomla pretty easily on my server at home, so I don't think you guys will have any trouble.
Joomla wins!
Voting is now over.
Please look forward to the new forum :-D
* holds breath *
Just wanted to update you and let you know that users have been successfully transferred to the new system. It took me a bit of work to get the forum itself installed; I didn't know Joomla didn't come with one by default.
Anyway, assuming things go well, I foresee an open beta of the new site on Saturday. The look will probably be a little rough until things get smoothed out, but at least we'll know whether or not the system is ready for prime time.
PS: Joomla rocks! It has quite a lot more features in its forums that have been requested here in the past.
PPS: I'm up really late here on the east coast. I'm going to bed.
Glad joomlas working for ya. Yeah, it's got a lot of plug ins, but most don't come with it, so you have to go to the source forge and get them. then you're dazzled by how many things you can do, so you download them all. lol.
I'm looking foward to seeing the new forum.
If you trying to decide on modules, I miss the RSS feeds and the polls.
Joomla comes with syndication abilities, but it'll probably take a bit to figure out how to set it up. The polls should be pretty easy.
Go Grim! I can't wait!
Just letting you know that I'm still in the middle of this. I hope to have it all setup before I go to bed. I'm just stuck trying to get the avatars to work right now.
After some work, the database ported beautifully. I'm still working out a few snags though; so, it likely won't be until Sunday evening before a beta is open. I'm going to be reaching a point soon where I need some sleep.
The primary snag I'm having right now is that while general topics are visible, the post subjects and content are not. They are there, and I can sneak my way into one. However, I need to get them publicly visible before giving out the URL to you guys.
P.S.: I'm going to need someone from CAOS to setup the interface. It's pretty much the joomla defaults with a lot of things removed by me.
So, I've been looking at the reason why the code tags don't work properly in the Joomla Fireboards forum module. I have no idea why. The code for that specific module is really fucked.
The code for Joomla? Really nice looking for PHP coders, but Fireboard is one big cesspool of amateur hacks.
So, to that end, I am going to reraise this issue and see if it would be alright with CAOS if we go with Simple Machines Forum (http://www.simplemachines.org/) instead? I can get it setup and can get started on porting the database too it, which will hopefully be easier as well. Fireboard uses more of a data warehouse layout, which is a better idea than a normalized database for the kind of accesses we get, but it makes the porting work more difficult.
Let me know what you think, and I'll get to it on some free time this week. Free time when I'm not at the gym, working, relaxing, sleeping, or working, or working, or working :-D
At this point... as long as it gets up, I don't care what we use.
Umm... no offense, but aren't there loads of other forum software for joomla? I know I went through three before I found one that suited me, even though all worked fine.
I just don't like SM boards either...
I don't care what we use anymore... We really just need a forum that works.