Computer Association of SIUE - Forums

CAOS Forums => News and Commentary => Topic started by: raptor on 2009-08-09T07:48:34-05:00 (Sunday)

Title: Which Search Engine would you use in a blind study? Find out
Post by: raptor on 2009-08-09T07:48:34-05:00 (Sunday)
Neat site that provides search results from Bing, Google and Yahoo without telling you which is which.  Fun experiment.
http://blindsearch.fejus.com/
Title: Re: Which Search Engine would you use in a blind study? Find out
Post by: Bryan on 2009-08-11T07:38:03-05:00 (Tuesday)
WOW!  I've been doing quite a bit of research on Tanzania and Mt. Kilimanjaro lately and figured I'd try some of the queries I'd been using.  Surprisingly enough, Google was provided the worst results...
Title: Re: Which Search Engine would you use in a blind study? Find out
Post by: William Grim on 2009-08-11T20:54:18-05:00 (Tuesday)
Well, I have a tough rme deciding.  I agree that google is doing a poor job in this test.  Yahoo and bing are much stronger contenders.  However, logged in as myself, google does a better overall job, because it's learned my search preferences.

Google still wins on its UI though.  I wish the Yahoo would simplify.  Bing is pretty good, but the main page's images really tuen me off.
Title: Re: Which Search Engine would you use in a blind study? Find out
Post by: arcdrag on 2009-08-12T12:10:55-05:00 (Wednesday)
Personally, all my results were almost identical.  Since google is the only search engine without a bunch of crap on the front page, I'll keep using it. 
Title: Re: Which Search Engine would you use in a blind study? Find out
Post by: Tangent Orchard on 2009-08-15T17:35:42-05:00 (Saturday)
I pretty much got results with a 60/40 preference for Google. :)